you're reading...

Why Italian pensioners didn’t have to pay the price

The unions questioned and challenged it time and again. Others who actually looked at the figures couldn’t under why. But the European Central Bank and the vast majority of Italy’s politicians were in agreement that a further ‘reform’ of the Italian pension system was absolutely indispensable.

And so it was in December that the government pushed through hefty hikes to the retirement age, to 66 by 2018, an end to indexation for pensions above EUR1,400 a month, and a move from earnings to contribution-based pensions. These amount to a €9bn ‘sacrifice’ by pensioners by 2014 alone. Elsa Fornero, welfare minister, who shed tears at the time, confessed that the state had ‘taken the hatchet’ to the pension system. Goldman Sachs said it was ‘the most important aspect’ of the Governnment’s austerity package.

But was it really necessary? It was interesting to hear representatives of the two main parties that backed these  ’reforms’ address this question on the Italian radio yesterday.

Roberto Colaninno, a wealthy businessman and former minister for the centrist Democrats, said:

‘We mustn’t forget that this reform originated as a result of a delay that we have accumulated…and also the fact that in December we found ourselves with the risk that Italy would blow up, taking not only the pensions system but also savings and the future with it, and thus this reform was the result an accumulated delay and also a threat of financial collapse…without this reform there probably wouldn’t have been any pensions for anybody …we were retracing the steps, at a few months’ distance, of nearby Greece…these measures, that we can even define as brutal, allowed our country to escape from bankruptcy and collapse…to come out of  intensive care and a deep coma.’

Alfredo Cazzola, another well-heeled businessman, and member of Silvio Berlusconi’s right-wing People of Freedom Party said:

‘I think the government has used pensions to send a strong signal to markets in Europe…the pension system itself had no major budgetary problems, however, let’s say when a country is tough on pensions, it gains credibility in international markets, that is, in reality, the pension [reforms] were a strong political signal that the Monti government wanted to send to the markets.’

Colaninno didn’t explain to listeners what was  unsound about the previous pension system, nor what he meant by an ‘accumulation of delays’. For in truth, following earlier reforms the Italian pension system was already considerably ahead of Germany and France, in the sense that these earlier changes made it considerably meaner with the elderly. The reform was justified with an “unless …” and an “if …”:  that old weapon of fear.  Italian citizens had accept unnecessary, hasty and unfair reforms, lest they end up like the Greeks.

Cazzola didn’t even bother pretending that changes were needed to improve the soundness of the retirement system. As he said, it ‘did not in itself had major budgetary  problems’ . Instead the real inspiration was to gain credibility with international speculators. The retired and retiring, he was clearly saying, were used as bargaining chips to cut bond spreads.

And that’s about it. Nothing to do with the government’s stated aims of a fairer burden between the generations, or putting the pension system on a sustainable footing.

The state pension fund was seen as an easy target to raid in order to patch up the public finances ruined by years of growth-destroying austerity policies and decades in which the state had been a soft touch on the rich and big business.

Could the Government have chosen another target?

Like tax dodgers who rob the state of more than €120 billion a year.

Or owners of yachts, ferraris, and vast property and share portfolios who won’t go hungry or be left homeless, or even miss a holiday if they each parted with some of their millions to help restore the public coffers? That 10% with 46% of Italy’s great riches, the few thousand families who own a sizeable chunk of the €9.5 trillion in assets known as household wealth. Yes, they could.

But for plutocrat Monti and his cabinet of millionaires it was simply easier to rob the powerless and now even more penniless pensioners. And cover it up with a big lie.

About revoltingeurope

Writer on Europe's Left, trade union and social movements @tomgilltweets or email [email protected]


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Twitter Updates

  • #Women's rights, #health being rolled back in Eastern #Europe as curbs on abortion spread. IPS shar.es/kgsJk 9 minutes ago
  • Why Greece is slashing public sector jobs wp.me/p1bMfw-1R3 16 hours ago
  • Flash mob performances hit #Italy's beaches, as #women campaign over domestic violence, deregulation . ANSA ansa.it/web/notizie/ru… 23 hours ago
  • While the #EU frets over #Hungary #Italy's democracy burns. My piece on Left Foot Forward leftfootforward.org/2013/07/it-is-… 1 day ago
  • #Troika destroys 500,000 jobs in #Portugal | Revolting #Europe wp.me/p1bMfw-1QW #imf #ecb 1 day ago
  • Close to half #Portugal's population running the risk of #poverty as #inequality increases. Portugal News theportugalnews.com/news/close-to-… 1 day ago
  • Copying UK's #austerity cuts sets us on a road to ruin: A view from Australia smh.com.au/federal-politi… via @smh 1 day ago
  • #Austerity suicides: Since crisis began, 16 police officers have taken own lives ekathimerini.com/4dcgi/_w_artic… #Greece 1 day ago
  • RT @ekathimerini AFP video feature on the rise of racist violence in #Greece youtube.com/watch?feature=… #austerity #racism 1 day ago
  • 'Girls should be able to go on TV without parading with a no.'House speaker on state tv axing of miss italia ansa.it/web/notizie/ru… 1 day ago
Follow @tomgilltweets

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


Key facts and figures on wages across the EU

Wealth Inequality in Europe

Get the key facts and figures


A different take on European issues

Italy’s Healthcare Crisis

Health services are ‘close to collapse’ in Rome, Turin and Naples after years of cuts and privatisation.


99% of the 167 000 Madrilenos who signed a petition rejected the sell off local water company

Filthy Rich

France's Bernard Arnault of the Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessy (LVMH) empire is worth $41 billion. Check out Europe's rich list


Private banks receive half-trillion-euro gift from ECB


Workers and citizens stand up for themselves


Workers are on a go-slow over privatisation

Massive Spanish protest

Half a million take to the streets over labour market deregulation


Hundreds of workers occupied the factory of ArcelorMittal in Florange in the north of France

International Workers Day

International Workers Day 2012


Anti-social Europe in numbers

RSS Watching Corporate Europe

  • MEPs code of conduct failing to prevent potential conflicts of interest
  • Robbing the "Robin Hood" tax: the European Central Bank weighs in
  • Appeal filed over business lobbies' privileged access in EU-India trade talks

RSS Hate Crimes in Europe

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Fight discrimination in Europe – Amnesty Int’l

  • Listen to Roma Rights
  • Peaceful Budapest Pride March, but a worrying hate attack following the march


in Italy the home is a very dangerous place to be


Workers down tools over PM Monti's attack on labour rights


Concentration camps and a massive migrant marine cemetery





Read the statement by Lafontaine and Melenchon

PM Rajoy One Year On

Spaniards are not impressed








The Dossier