you're reading...
Germany, Greece

The German elections will not change a thing in the Eurozone

Interview with Italian economist Emiliano Brancaccio

‘As far as austerity is concerned, even after the September elections Germany will not turn the page. The Germans have benefited from the crisis, and even if the Bundesbank itself has reservations about the general direction of European economic policy, Berlin has no interest in changing course.’

So says Emiliano Brancaccio, researcher and professor of Economics at the University of Sannio. A report by the Bundesbank said that Greece will need further aid by the spring of 2014, in a clear, if indirect criticism of the policies of German Chancellor Angela Merkel.

Brancaccio, how do you explain the Bundesbank’s criticism of Merkel?

For about two years a dialectic has developed in Germany where the Bundesbank is skeptical about the effectiveness of European economic policy. The German central bank says it wants more rigor from countries requesting aid to cover their debts, but it appears to be just an excuse, a smokescreen. In reality, the Bundesbank embodies the position of those who harbour growing doubts about the future survival of the euro zone.

Upon what facts do these doubts rest?

From the fact that austerity is missing its targets. During the 2000s, with the approval of the financial markets and the major European banks, Greece was able to accumulate foreign debt of as much as 18% of GDP per annum – and almost never below 10%. At the time, the operators on the financial markets were euphoric, and the creditors were optimistic about the possibility of repaying the loans. Economists who raised the alarm about the unsustainability of those debts were ignored. Now, however, the mood has changed. The creditors now demand that Greece completely changes its position with respect to foreign creditors and starts to immediately pay off its debts. According to its proponents, the policy of “austerity” should serve exactly this purpose: bring down the income and therefore imports of the Greeks, so much to transform the external debt of the country into a surplus. But the data tells us that it is failing .


The forecasts of the European Commission show that Greece, despite the sacrifices of austerity, will not be able to absorb its foreign debt, either this year or next year: in 2014 it is expected to remain with a foreign deficit of 1.7%. Meanwhile, the country has now reached unemployment rates of 27% in 2013, and it is expected that in 2014 the rate will not fall below 26%. The truth is that, in endorsing the policies of austerity, we are only helping to destroy the Greek economy without being able to reverse its debt exposure to foreign creditors.

Can granting fresh aid to Greece have a positive effect?

Not as it stands. The financing provided by the EU institutions and by the ECB for Greece and other peripheral countries require, as compensation, tremendous austerity policies. But this exchange is contradictory: in fact these policies depress domestic spending and so slash production and incomes in the peripheral countries to such an extent as to render more difficult the recovery of debts.

Why does the Bundesbank, while realizing that EU policies do not work, continue to stand as a bulwark of austerity?

Because it has no interest in changing its line. We must understand that the European crisis is strongly asymmetric. While the peripheral countries, such as Greece, Spain, Portugal, Italy and Ireland have lost – since the crisis began up until today – 6 million jobs, Germany has not been affected to the same degree. Indeed, from 2008 to 2012 in Germany the number of jobs actually increased by 1.5 million. Though it might take note of the fact that austerity will not solve the crisis in Europe, at the same time there is no political reason to think that Germany is willing to change course.

But the collapse of exports in the EU, according to the IMF, will ensure that this year German growth will fall to just 0.3%. Will Germany also start paying the bill [for austerity]?

Without a doubt, the German economy has grown for years on the basis of a mechanism that does not work anymore. International creditors, largely German, financed public and private debt in peripheral countries. These, in turn, used a good part of the loans to import goods from Germany. And this is the mechanism through which, from the birth of the euro, Germany has been able to thrive.

Why has this mechanism broken down?

Because it is an asymmetric mechanism, which feeds imbalances between creditors and debtors. Sooner or later it was bound to explode. Germany is surely concerned that it can no longer rely on it. But we should not delude ourselves that Berlin will give the green light to a season of expansionary policies in Europe. Some commentators hope that after the German elections we can catch a glimpse of a breakthrough. In particular, they hope that Germany finally agrees to buy goods from abroad in order to raise sales and the income of the peripheral countries. On these hopes, I personally remain skeptical. The Germans have never acted as a locomotive of European demand: on the contrary, they have always claimed to be towed by demand from abroad. The crisis affects them too little to think that they will abruptly change strategy.

Interview originally published by ilsussidiario, August 13, 2013. Interview by Peter Vernizzi

Emiliano Brancaccio blog

Translation by Revolting Europe

About revoltingeurope

Writer on Europe's Left, trade union and social movements @tomgilltweets or email [email protected]



  1. Pingback: The German elections will not change a thing in the Eurozone | Left Futures - August 15, 2013

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Twitter Updates

  • Europe has more and fatter fat cats new figures show wp.me/p1bMfw-1Uw 1 day ago
  • #Italy: Tens of thousands of #students take to streets to demand investment in #education | Revolting #Europe wp.me/p1bMfw-1Ur 1 day ago
  • A Week in Revolting #Europe wp.me/p1bMfw-16u #politics #spain #austerity #inequality #racism #fascism #socialism #protest #wages 1 day ago
  • Pensioners gathered in Madrid's Puerto del Sol today in #protest at govt cuts to their #pensions. Video (in Spanish) youtu.be/DyZ9z1ZWEYQ 5 days ago
  • Over 30 percent of #Greeks at risk of #poverty (in 2011, before a further two years of recession). ekathimerini ekathimerini.com/4dcgi/_w_artic… 5 days ago
  • #France's battle over Sunday opening hours | Revolting #Europe wp.me/p1bMfw-1Ue via @tomgilltweets 1 week ago
  • Should French shops open on Sundays? | Revolting Europe wp.me/p1bMfw-1Ue 1 week ago
  • Swiss to vote on 2,500 franc basic income for every adult eurone.ws/19ncwAk #equality #pay #FTT 1 week ago
  • A Week in Revolting #Europe wp.me/p1bMfw-16u #Germany #elections #politics #spain #austerity #italy #france #greece #portugal #banks 1 week ago
  • Depressed #Greece (and others in EZ) needs #debt-relief or its #Euro-exit ekathimerini/Bloomberg ekathimerini.com/4dcgi/_w_artic… via @ekathimerini 1 week ago
Follow @tomgilltweets

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


Key facts and figures on wages across the EU

Wealth Inequality in Europe

Get the key facts and figures


A different take on European issues

Italy’s Healthcare Crisis

Health services are ‘close to collapse’ in Rome, Turin and Naples after years of cuts and privatisation.


99% of the 167 000 Madrilenos who signed a petition rejected the sell off local water company

Filthy Rich

France's Bernard Arnault of the Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessy (LVMH) empire is worth $41 billion. Check out Europe's rich list


Private banks receive half-trillion-euro gift from ECB


Workers and citizens stand up for themselves


Workers are on a go-slow over privatisation

Massive Spanish protest

Half a million take to the streets over labour market deregulation


Hundreds of workers occupied the factory of ArcelorMittal in Florange in the north of France

International Workers Day

International Workers Day 2012


Anti-social Europe in numbers

RSS Watching Corporate Europe

  • A Brave New Transatlantic Partnership: the social & environmental consequences of the proposed EU-US trade deal
  • Polish government's official climate website in (volcanic) hot water after giving platform to climate deniers
  • EU lobby register review: Parliament vice-president for transparency opposed to improved transparency?

RSS Hate Crimes in Europe

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Fight discrimination in Europe – Amnesty Int’l

  • Listen to Roma Rights


in Italy the home is a very dangerous place to be


Workers down tools over PM Monti's attack on labour rights


Concentration camps and a massive migrant marine cemetery





Read the statement by Lafontaine and Melenchon

PM Rajoy One Year On

Spaniards are not impressed








The Dossier