you're reading...
Italy, Politics

The Euro is a dead man walking

Italians have decided – the Euro is now a zombie. It’s time to Exit, from the left says economist Emiliano Brancaccio

‘Signor Euro repeatedly risked a heart attack. Dr. Draghi then decided to put him in an induced coma. With respect to the cure, though, he hesitated. At regular intervals, a Hamlet-like dilemma presented itself: let him sleep or kill him or l? Draghi insisted on the former. But suddenly the Italian people opted for the latter: the euro is now just a zombie, a dead man walking. Like it or not, let’s take note.’

On 24-25 February, ‘populist’ (Pirate?) comedian blogger Beppe Grillo and his upstart Five Star Movement emerged as the single largest party, on the back of a Euro-skeptic, anti-austerity platform. The pro-European centre-Left Democrats, even with their alliance on the left with Puglia governor Nichi Vendola’s SEL, and potentially the votes of former PM Mario Monti on the right, failed to win the hoped for majorities in both houses. Silvio Berlusconi’s right wing coalition, that of late took a distinctly anti-European position, secured almost as many votes as the Democrats.

In a blog posting earlier this week, one of Italy’s foremost progressive economists, Emiliano Brancaccio, argues that no-one should be in any doubt that Italians have given a resounding NO vote to the Single Currency. And Germany certainly won’t be, and will be making plans for exit of the Eurozone’s third largest economy – and potentially the end of the Euro project itself. As for Italy it is a question not of whether, but how it will exit from the Currency Union.

Germany and the ECB

Brancaccio predicts that the Germany-dominated ECB will now start manoeuvering to revert to its non-interventionist form. That is, standing by and letting the ‘markets’ find their balance, whatever the economic and social cost. It wind down the European Financial Stability Facility, which, made up of hundreds of billions of euros from member states (with Germany the largest contributer), was designed to ‘bail-out’ governments and banks in the Eurozone (in return for which they would relinquish to European authorities sovereignty over key financial and economic policy decisions). And it will end its policy of purchasing of sovereign bonds in Greece, Spain, Italy and other struggling Eurozone members. Initially fiercely opposed by the German elite, this was ostensibly designed to bring down bond ‘spreads’ – the borrowing costs that have soared as their economies plunge and debts rise – although it was also a covert way of bailing out the global banking system and made no impact on lending to the real economy (and here).

Says Brancaccio:

‘The most dire predictions of an appeal by 300 economists, published in June 2010, are therefore coming true. The ECB’s claim that it would only protect against speculative attacks countries which devoted themselves to the discipline of austerity, proved to be a resounding failure, both in logic and politically. Italy, which gave the world the Renaissance but also Fascism, has decided that for the euro, there’s nothing left but to recite the De Profundis….​European technocrats, conditioned by the prevailing interests in Germany, have been digging the grave in which to bury the Single Currency for a long time…Germany is no longer interested in the single currency, the hopes for reform of the monetary union are now buried. There’s only one question: how to get out of the eurozone.’

So, he argues, the choices before Italy are what path it chooses to leave the Euro – will be an exit by the Right or the Left?

Exit from the Right

‘As things stand, the most likely way it will happen is by following a “right-wing” path, which would be to promote capital flight, open up bank capital to foreign acquisitions as well as the last major pieces of national industrial capital, and leave wages completely unprotected in the face of a possible surge in prices and especially widening inequalities of income. One can expect to see not only Berlusconi but also many others consider this solution. The so-called “enlightened bourgeoisie’ hordes of mainsteam pundits, will rush to rediscover their virginity, judging the euro a Kantian ideal doomed from the beginning, exhuming Milton Friedman and flexible exchange rates and devaluation in order to make the country attractive to foreign capital on the hunt for cheap acquisitions.

‘The single currency can go to hell, they will cry out, the important thing is to save the single market and the free movement of capital from the so-called populist protectionist instincts! Well, if things go that way, there is reason to fear that the explosion of the euro zone could be a veritable massacre. Moreover, anyone who has studied the economic history of the last century knows that monetary sovereignty, taken in isolation, is not a panacea, and that it was not at all uncommon for the release from a fixed exchange rate regime to have produced a real disaster in terms of the liquidation of the national capital and the destruction of the last remnants of social rights.

‘Of course, it does not always end badly, but in some cases and for some it did indeed go badly. To cite just a few examples: in 1992, after Italy exited the European Monetary System (EMS), the wage share of national wealth fell from 62% to 54%. In 1994-1995, after depreciation, Turkey, Mexico and Argentina recorded a fall in real wages respectively 31%, 19% and 5% in a year, and after the devaluation of 1998, Indonesia, South Korea and Thailand real wages fell by 44%, 10% and 6% (data ILO and World Bank). Not to mention the “fire sales” of national capital favoured by devaluation. The restoration of monetary sovereignty is imperative, but doing it the right-wing way could turn into a nightmare.’

Exit from the Left

‘This is not, however, inevitable. There is also an alternative way to manage the implosion of the eurozone, which is the attempt to build a social bloc around a hypothesis of ‘left’ exit from the euro. That is, in the first place: a stop on capital flight; nationalization, instead of foreign acquisitions of bank capital; an indexation mechanism of wages and control of some prices of basic goods to manage the changes in income distribution; the idea of a free trade area among the countries of Southern Europe. In short, a ‘Left’ solution should focus on the idea that if you leave the single currency you must also call into question some aspects of the European single market.’

What will be the role of the heirs of Italy’s communist, labour movement, the trade union central CGIL and Pierluigi Bersani’s centre-left Democrats?

Brancaccio argues both the Democrats and the trade unions need to take a reality check on any prospects of ‘more Europe’, that is policies on further ‘convergence’ in the financial, economic or social field. ‘Even they see the iceberg now, and maybe they even realize that at stake is their own survival, as the fate of the Pasok [in Greece] teaches.’

And Grillo?

‘To see whether the conditions exist to form a social coalition around a hypothesis of a “left” exit from the Euro also means putting the Five Star Movement to the test. Which, even though it has the wind in its sales, can hardly govern alone, and will in any case soon face the inescapable dilemma of any economic policy, to give priority to small business owners and entrepreneurs, or find a synthesis with the interests of workers.

Emiliano Brancaccio’s blog

Translation by Revolting Europe

About revoltingeurope

Writer on Europe's Left, trade union and social movements @tomgilltweets or email [email protected]


5 thoughts on “The Euro is a dead man walking

  1. I’m afraid you may be right. Certainly I agree about your recommendation of a left exit, if an exit shall be. I’d like to think that there is still hope for the German public to realize that their elite, and Merkel, and destroying Europe and kick her out before it’s too late.

    Posted by Pavlos | March 1, 2013, 8:53 pm
    • If am not German I would do not pay attenzione to Germany at all. Michael Parenti told in 2002, see videos on youtube, that what globalization means is globalization of powerty. Basic think is to cut all freetrade agreements, even inside European Union. Then make a law that any corporation which is making business ro selling products, including China etc, in country should make sister company in country directly for tax purpose. This will force German and tax heaven companies, like those registered on Cayman Islands and Liechtenstein, pay corporate taxes in country from volume of their business in country.

      Including China is very important, because this will allow China selling their products directly in country not thru merchants who make money on it without investment, this will also cut corruption for protectionism. China is not allowed to do business directly because of human rights fancy criticims but merchant corporation can sell Made in China products anywhere. Doubble standard. Then I will make business with those companies by barter. I will reject any export-imoprt inter countries agreements and I would do it directly by corporations to fill needs in my country. In capitalism countries do not own factories, all is in private hands so why talking with government in other country about my own demands?

      Look at free trade. Corporations are allowed move capital and goods thru borders worldwide without taxes, but 99% can not. Try buy something directly over internet from USA or China. You will pay import tax, right? First protest on US soil known as Boston tea party was against tax exemption of one single company: British East India Company. This merchant company operates till this days but renamed. It would be great to know names of shareholders of BEIC and compare them with shareholders of corporations in our days. I bet there would be direct descendandts.

      If I am Mr Grillo I would, instead of exit Euro, talk about this. That will scary them to death.

      Most funny think on Euroland is that EU has freetrade agreements with tax heavens as Liechtenstein. So companies registered there pay taxes in Liechtenstein only.

      Posted by Francesca | March 2, 2013, 2:06 pm
  2. Cool hot Italian blood. It is not necessary to exit from Euro. Actually would not do it at all in any case. Oposite way I would hold it as oficial or unoficial currency. There are countries who solved their problems with doubble currency better and easier than single national currency. Single national currency is extremely vurnerable to attack by vultures from Bank for International Setlements. They can easy destroy it. What Germany did during 1930′s was:
    1, they kept Deatsche Mark as official currency but in reality abandoned it. They did not do any business with DM. Actually it was not currency but something like food stamps.Totaly out of control of international banksters.
    2, They did lots of barter trade so actually they totaly detoured banksters.

    “Hitler and the National Socialists, who came to power in 1933, thwarted the international banking cartel by issuing their own money. In this they took their cue from Abraham Lincoln, who funded the American Civil War with government-issued paper money called “Greenbacks.” Hitler began his national credit program by devising a plan of public works. Projects earmarked for funding included flood control, repair of public buildings and private residences, and construction of new buildings, roads, bridges, canals, and port facilities. The projected cost of the various programs was fixed at one billion units of the national currency. One billion non-inflationary bills of exchange, called Labor Treasury Certificates, were then issued against this cost. Millions of people were put to work on these projects, and the workers were paid with the Treasury Certificates. This government-issued money wasn’t backed by gold, but it was backed by something of real value. It was essentially a receipt for labor and materials delivered to the government. Hitler said, “for every mark that was issued we required the equivalent of a mark’s worth of work done or goods produced.” The workers then spent the Certificates on other goods and services, creating more jobs for more people.” Ellen Brown,

    Guernsey, Jersey and Isle of Man has also 2 currencies without problems for centuries.

    Currently the same trick is using Ecuador with my Man el presidente Rafael Correa. Unoficially oficial currency in Ecuador is US dollar. They have their own currency but nobody cares about it. But they are not connected to US Federal Reserve. If BIS wants to hurt Ecuador should attack US dollar. Wawa viva. Smart man, Mr Correa.

    And here is my soul brother who explain you how it worx. I told Ye before about Silvio Gesell. Pay attenzione ti this guy. We have currency in Switzerland called WIR. WIR is used in trade in 1 bilion Swiss Frank volume.

    “The Swiss WIR, or: How to Defeat the Money Power”

    Ya can find some ideas here: The Fight Against usury, Juri Lina

    I agree with Mr Grillo with withdraw from NATO, cut all free trade agreements, limited membership in EU, but on Euro I disagree at all. There is safer way to achieve our goal: Get out from cyber slavery of banksters

    Posted by Francesca | March 2, 2013, 12:30 pm
  3. I think banksters have fun from Mr Grillo. They know ahead how they will destroy reinvented Lira- with great help of Mrs Berlusconi, Agnelli, Monti etc. They will destroy Italy with Lira and then they will have example to show how Euro is important. They are setting trap right now. They just play commedy with talks how Italy’s withdraw, or any other country, from Euro will hurt Euro. They have plan set, they have tools and know how. Orwell was right when he said: “Who control the past…” Learn history before repeats on YOU! There is way to obey banksters and I gave you material for study. If Mr Grillo will start talk about this, then he will scary them

    Posted by Francesca | March 2, 2013, 1:13 pm
  4. I forgot this link

    Posted by Francesca | March 2, 2013, 1:15 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Twitter Updates

  • A Week in Revolting Europe paper.li/tomgilltweets/… #austerity #politics #poverty #inequality #protest #banks #pensions #wages #unions 1 week ago
  • A Gathering Storm: Eurozone in 2014 | Jacques Sapir | Revolting Europe wp.me/p1bMfw-1XC 1 week ago
  • RT @labourstart: France: Two Total refineries in France to shut down over strikes ow.ly/rNovF 1 week ago
  • RT @USILive: Banking Union without Reform? - usilive.org/banking-union-… 1 week ago
  • EU credit downgrade 'pours cold water on narrative that things getting better in eurozone' -The Economist. economist.com/blogs/charlema… #austerity 1 week ago
  • RT @corporateeurope: 'Elected politicians excluded from #EU-US negotiations', writes @StaffaniDK #TTIP notat.dk/elected-politi… 1 week ago
  • Women plan mass #protests in #Spain today against law changes taking abortion rights back 30 years newsinfo.inquirer.net/549871/spain-s… 1 week ago
  • RT @euronews: Major austerity drive in Portugal deemed illegal eurone.ws/JOjqV8 1 week ago
  • RT @SocialEurope: Read on SEJ: Why Wage Depression Is Not The Way Out For Spain bit.ly/19xQlGP 1 week ago
  • Families of kids with special needs issue SOS as disability benefits cut & schools cost too much ekathimerini.com/4dcgi/_w_artic… #austerity #greece 2 weeks ago
Follow @tomgilltweets

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


Anti-social Europe in numbers


Key facts and figures on wages across the EU

Wealth Inequality in Europe

Get the key facts and figures


A different take on European issues

Italy’s Healthcare Crisis

Health services are ‘close to collapse’ in Rome, Turin and Naples after years of cuts and privatisation.


99% of the 167 000 Madrilenos who signed a petition rejected the sell off local water company

Filthy Rich

France's Bernard Arnault of the Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessy (LVMH) empire is worth $41 billion. Check out Europe's rich list


Private banks receive half-trillion-euro gift from ECB


Workers and citizens stand up for themselves


Workers are on a go-slow over privatisation

Massive Spanish protest

Half a million take to the streets over labour market deregulation


Hundreds of workers occupied the factory of ArcelorMittal in Florange in the north of France

International Workers Day

International Workers Day 2012

RSS Watching Corporate Europe

  • Pesticides, tobacco and greedy lawyers: the most read stories from CEO in 2013
  • EFSA urged to clean up list of 'public interest' organisations
  • NGOs welcome Ombudsman’s damning report which heavily criticises Commission

RSS Hate Crimes in Europe

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Fight discrimination in Europe – Amnesty Int’l

  • Listen to Roma Rights
  • Russia: Total disregard for human rights on “Constitution Day”


in Italy the home is a very dangerous place to be


Workers down tools over PM Monti's attack on labour rights


Concentration camps and a massive migrant marine cemetery





Read the statement by Lafontaine and Melenchon

PM Rajoy One Year On

Spaniards are not impressed








The Dossier